Woefkesranch

Sterilisation or castration in dogs: pros and cons

When you take your puppy to the vet for the first time, the vet will often bring up castration or sterilisation straight away. As a new puppy owner, you have often not yet thought about whether you actually want that. At Woefkesranch we regularly receive questions about this topic. Castrating or sterilising your dog may have some advantages, but it certainly also has a great many disadvantages, especially when we look at castration in dogs!

What is castration?

In castration, the testicles are removed from a male dog and the ovaries and uterus are removed from a female. It is also possible to sterilise your dog, but sterilisation is almost never performed anymore. Although sterilisation is less invasive, castration is usually carried out.

Is castration advisable?

Castration has more consequences for a dog than it may seem at first, especially in young dogs. The hormones needed for general, physical and mental development are missing. This often results in negative effects. For example, natural behavioural changes, including the development of adult behaviour in a male dog, do not always occur after the operation. Also consider muscle development and skeletal growth.

Unfortunately, we are seeing an increase in health problems in dogs that were castrated early. Think of skeletal abnormalities, patellar luxation, etc.

There are several long-term studies on the consequences of castration. They raise doubts as to whether the benefits outweigh the disadvantages. We may even have to conclude that castration, unless medically necessary, is an unwise and unnecessary medical procedure.

You can question the idea that neutered animals would be healthier, happier, or live longer.

Female dogs in heat and humping males

Also ask yourself whether you are really that bothered by the heat of a female dog, or by a male’s temporary macho behaviour and humping.

Castratie bij honden

The positive and negative aspects according to Laura Sanborn

The American veterinarian Laura Sanborn published an article about the results of a study she conducted on the effects of spaying and neutering dogs.

The conclusions from Laura Sanborn’s study are listed below:

In male dogs:

The positive aspects of neutering:

  • Eliminating the small risk of testicular cancer (probably less than 1%).
  • Reducing the risk of benign prostate problems
  • Reducing the risk of fistulas
  • Possibly reducing the risk of diabetes (no data available)

The negative aspects:

  • If you have your dog neutered before the age of 1 year, the risk of bone cancer increases noticeably.
  • Bone cancer has a very poor prognosis.
  • An increase in the risk of the heart condition haemangiosarcoma (blood vessel cancer) by a factor of 1.6.
  • The risk of mast cell tumours (skin tumours), lymph node cancer and all other forms of cancer increases significantly.
  • The risk of an underactive thyroid (hypothyroidism) triples.
  • The risk of becoming overweight triples.
  • The small risk of prostate cancer (less than 0.6%) quadruples.
  • The small risk of bladder cancer (less than 1%) doubles.
  • The risk of bone problems increases.
  • The risk of adverse reactions to vaccination increases by 27 – 38%.
  • The risk of behavioural problems, especially anxiety/insecurity, aggression and/or reactive behaviour, increases. If neutered at a young age, this also increases the risk of noise phobias and unwanted sexual behaviour such as “mounting”.
In female dogs:

The positive aspects of neutering:

  • If a female dog is spayed before she is 2.5 years old, the risk of mammary tumours is significantly reduced. Mammary tumours are benign in 50% of cases and malignant in 50% of cases. Because they can be felt externally, they are discovered relatively quickly and are then easily removed surgically. With timely detection, the prognosis is therefore very favourable.
  • The risk of uterine infection (pyometra) becomes virtually zero.
  • The risk of fistulas is reduced.
  • The very small risk (less than 0.5%) of bladder, uterine and ovarian cancer disappears.

The downsides:

  • Neutering before the first year of life significantly increases the risk of bone cancer. Bone cancer has a very poor prognosis.
  • The risk of spleen problems increases by a factor of 2.2 and of heart problems by a factor of 5 or more. These are haemangiosarcomas (blood vessel cancer). These relatively common cancers are among the leading causes of death in several breeds.
  • The risk of mast cell tumours (skin tumours), lymphoma and all other forms of cancer increases significantly.
  • The risk of reduced thyroid function (hypothyroidism) triples.
  • The risk of becoming overweight increases by a factor of 1.6 – 2.
  • Spayed females have a 22 times higher risk of acute pancreatitis (inflammation of the pancreas).
  • Neutering can cause urinary incontinence in 4–20% of females.
  • The risk of chronic bladder problems and inflammation increases by a factor of 3–4.
  • The risk of vulvar problems such as infections increases, especially in females spayed before their first heat.
  • The small risk (less than 1%) of tumours in the urinary tract doubles.
  • The risk of bone problems increases.
  • The risk of adverse reactions to vaccination increases by 27 – 38%.
  • The risk of behavioural problems, especially anxiety/insecurity, aggression or reactive behaviour, increases.
  • If neutered at a young age, this also increases the risk of noise phobias and unwanted sexual behaviour such as ‘mounting’.

Results of the study “Long-Term Health Risks and Benefits Associated with Spay / Neuter in Dogs”
by Laura J. Sanborn M.S.

If you want to read this article in full, you can click this link.

The effect of neutering on the dog’s coat

Neutering and/or spaying in dogs also has a major impact on their coat. In many cases the coat changes, and we then speak of a ‘neuter coat’.

We found an article about this on doggo, written on behalf of Groomers Europe by Jessica Kremer-Frijling of the Trimacademie:

Although there is little scientific evidence, owners, veterinarians, breeders and groomers do observe changes in the coat or even coat problems as a result. How a coat will react to neutering, however, depends on several factors such as coat type, the amount of coat before neutering, the age at neutering and undoubtedly other factors.

Stérilisation chien
Photo Annet-Vervat: English Cocker Spaniel after neutering.

In broad terms we often see more undercoat formation, making the coat duller and less rich in colour. We also see that the coat becomes curlier. More undercoat hairs result in a softer coat that is less water- and dirt-repellent, so it stays wet longer, gets dirty sooner and starts to smell faster. Softer hair also mats more quickly. In Spaniels and Setters the coats often seem to ‘explode’ with many dull, soft and longer hairs. The hair (undercoat and guard hair) continues to grow and appears to have a much longer shedding cycle. In contrast, in rough-haired breeds we often see less (or suddenly hardly any) undercoat and plucking sometimes seems to become more difficult.

Alopecia X

A notable exception to the rule is the effect of castration on double-coated dogs with the condition alopecia X. (Double-coated dogs are breeds such as Bernese Mountain Dogs, Golden Retriever, Shepherds, Newfoundlands, Pomeranians et cetera.) The name says it: baldness caused by X. In this case X is unknown. The condition causes progressive hair loss, ultimately resulting in baldness.

Based on the results of a study, the cause appears to be a hormonal imbalance. A study of 35 male Pomeranians of various ages, followed for 10 years after castration, found that in 42.9% of the dogs the coat had fully regrown within six months of castration and stayed that way for the following 3-9 years. For this disorder, castration therefore has a positive effect.

What can groomers do?

As a breeder and groomer I am not in favour of castration, but I am pragmatic enough not to see it only in black and white. There are plenty of examples, including alopecia X, where castration is justified or even necessary.

More maintenance

For many owners, coat care after castration is, however, much more difficult than before: the coat becomes thicker, the dog has more difficulty going through the moult or even sheds all year round. In practice this means more frequent and more intensive care for the owner. More frequent combing to keep the coat tangle-free, but not unnecessarily often either, because that would throw the shedding completely out of balance.

Would you like to read the full article? Then click on this link.

Our advice

We are not in favour of castrating puppies before they are adult and fully grown. If you are considering castrating an adult dog, we ask you to weigh up the pros and cons carefully.